Minutes:
The Chairman welcomed all participants to the virtual meeting and in doing so, checked that Members of the Sub-Committee, officers and the Applicant were all present.
It was noted that Mrs. K. Prust was in attendance on behalf of the applicant Mr. I. Prust.
The Chairman asked the applicant’s representative if she had been made aware that she could be represented by a legal representative at her own expense during the Hearing. The applicant’s representative confirmed that she had been made aware and was happy for the Hearing to continue.
Councillor A. D. Kriss, confirmed that he had carried out an unannounced Site Visit to the proposed trading site. Councillors S. J. Baxter and M. Thompson both stated that they were familiar with the area.
The Sub-Committee then considered an application for a street trading consent to sell hot and cold food and drinks from a unit sited on the car park at Bromsgrove Rugby Football Club, Finstall Road, Bromsgrove, Worcestershire, B60 3DH.
The Technical Officer, Worcestershire Regulatory Services (WRS) outlined the details of the application, together with the reasons why the application had been brought before the Sub-Committee.
It was confirmed that a representation had been received from Finstall Parish Council, as detailed at Appendix 2 to the report; and representations from residents and property owners adjacent to the proposed trading site, as detailed at Appendix 3 to the report.
At the invitation of the Chairman, Mrs. Prust, the applicant’s representative was asked to put forward the case in support of the application.
Mrs. Prust informed Members that she was part owner of the pizza business, which was a family run company that had been running for 7 years; primarily attending weddings, events, and festivals. However, they had looked at ways to diversify, as all of their bookings had been cancelled due to the Covid-19 pandemic; so, they had attended ‘pop up’ events in and around Bromsgrove and the surrounding areas and also supplied homemade pizza kits. The Foodie Friday’s at Bromsgrove Rugby Football Club was one of the ‘pop up’ events they had attended.
In response to questions from Sub-Committee Members, Mrs., Prust explained that they did not trade on match days or at the beer festival held at Bromsgrove Rugby Football Club, so that was not their customer base. Largely customers did come from the rugby club, but they also advertised. Customers could pre-order pizzas to be collected from them at the rugby club at an agreed time. The actual rugby club was closed due to Covid-19 restrictions.
Mrs. Prust also clarified that unit they used was moved away from their trading site, only the pizza oven and canopy were left parked right by the wall at the back of the clubhouse, they did not park on the front car park so did not take up any parking spaces.
In response to further questions from Sub-Committee Members, Mrs. Prust highlighted that they held a trade waste agreement with Bromsgrove District Council. They were very conscientious and absolutely ensured that there was no litter left at the trading site before they left the site. It was instilled in all of their staff to check the site for any litter.
In summing up Mrs. Prust reiterated that they ran a well-established business and lived in the Bromsgrove area and that they had very high standards.
At the invitation of the Chairman, the Council’s Legal Advisor drew Members’ attention to page 28 of the main agenda report the ‘Key Considerations. Members were further advised that even though those who had submitted representations had not attended the virtual meeting it did not detract from their objections.
Members should be mindful of only those matters which fell within the Street Trading Policy.
One of the representations received referred to over parking during match days and the beer festival at the club. Members should note that the Street Trading Consent proposed trading hours were each Friday 4pm to 8pm. Mrs. Prust had also highlighted that they did not trade at the site on match days or when the beer festival was held,
Members should consider any impact on road safety or putting pedestrians in danger when leaving or entering the site in order to use this particular street trading unit; and to determine if the unit would have any impact on parking. The concerns raised with regards to over parking on match days and during the beer festival were not related to the siting of this unit as highlighted by Mrs. Prust, as they did not trade on match days or at the beer festival.
The Sub-Committee then adjourned to consider its decision, upon its return it was
RESOLVED that the application for a Street Trading Consent be granted.
Having had regard to:
· The written application and oral representations provided at the Hearing by Mrs. K. Prust, the applicant’s representative.
· The written objection from Finstall Parish Council, as detailed on page 15 of the main agenda report.
· The written objection from a residential neighbour, as detailed on pages 16 to 18, of the main agenda report.
The Sub-Committee decided to allow Mr. Prust’s application to proceed.
The reasons for the Sub-Committee’s decision were as follows:
· In considering the objections received from Finstall Parish Council and the residential neighbour, with regards to their concerns over increased car parking congestion, Members noted that there had not been any objection from the responsible authorities in particular Highways whose primary concern would be around road safety.
The following legal advice was given:
There was no right of appeal against the decision of the Licensing Sub-Committee.
Supporting documents: